Evidence item · v0.74
Global Workspace explains access, not qualia
E-GWT-QUALIA-GAP
Visual overview: Global Workspace and qualia gap visual overview
Classification
- Evidence ID
- E-GWT-QUALIA-GAP
- Corpus/version
- v0.74
- Stage
- stage2
- Category
- Consciousness & Mind
- Major category
- Science
- Sub-category
- Cognitive Neuroscience
- BF status
- ready
- Scoring label
- Scored row with active Bayes factors
Navigation
Primary Datum
Datum: Global Workspace models explain access and report better than they explain felt experience itself.
Scoring / Hypothesis Pressure
| Hypothesis | log10BF | Min | Max | Rationale |
|---|---|---|---|---|
H-EMERGENTISM | 0.01 | -0.03 | 0.05 | Emergentist accounts can accept functional workspace explanations while treating phenomenal consciousness as higher-level; differential support is slight. |
H-GOD | 0.01 | -0.03 | 0.05 | Theism can accommodate mind as fundamental, but GWT/qualia debates do not directly establish God. |
H-IDEALISM | 0.04 | -0.01 | 0.09 | Global Workspace models explain access, report, and broadcast functions while leaving phenomenal feel contested; this modestly favors mind-first accounts, capped because E-CONSCIOUSNESS carries the broader hard-problem weight. |
H-NATURALISM | -0.01 | -0.05 | 0.04 | The pressure on broad naturalism is small because naturalism includes non-reductive, emergent, and illusionist options. |
H-PHYSICALISM-REDUCTIVE | -0.03 | -0.08 | 0.03 | A remaining access/qualia gap mildly pressures reductive physicalism, though identity and illusionist strategies remain live. |
Dependency / Cap Metadata
- dependency_cluster_id
- consciousness_mind
- dependency_cluster_role
- sibling_support
- dependency_cluster
- consciousness_mind
- dependency_role
- sibling_support
- cap_profile
- moderate_semi_independent
- evidence_function
- context_child
- directness
- supporting
Counter-Pressure
- title
- Brain explanations are real; reduction is the extra claim.
- text
- Global Workspace explains access, not qualia may give naturalism real local pressure by showing how much mind depends on brain. The Christian answer should welcome that. But dependence is not identity, and correlation is not a full account of first-person life, truth, moral responsibility, and love.
- path
- Let neuroscience explain the machinery. Then ask whether the machinery explains the person. A Christian can say humans are embodied souls or ensouled bodies without pretending thought floats free from the brain. The hard question is whether matter alone can carry meaning.
Apologetic Note
- label
- Apologetic leverage
- title
- People are harder to explain than brain scans are to describe.
- key point
- Global Workspace explains access, not qualia matters because neuroscience can describe brain activity without fully explaining what it is like to be a person who knows truth, loves, chooses, feels guilt, prays, and asks what life means.
- conversation move
- Welcome the science. Then use a simple distinction: explaining the instrument is not the same as explaining the music. Brain processes matter, but the person doing the thinking is still the deeper mystery.
- caveat
- Do not deny the brain. Christianity says persons are embodied. The point is that persons look like more than chemistry talking to itself.
Caveats / Notes
- Cap notes
- This row belongs to the consciousness and mind family. Its force should remain inspectable while overlap with sibling mind/reason rows is governed in cap diagnostics.
- Cap profile note
- Semi-independent convergence rows are capped, but not treated as exact duplicates.
- Scoring note
- Modernized from legacy Stage-1 refs. Dependent qualia-gap support only; do not stack freely with E-CONSCIOUSNESS.
Citations
- Dehaene, S. (2014). Consciousness and the Brain.
- Chalmers, D. (2010). The Character of Consciousness.
Recommended Citation
The Signal Evidence Dataset, "Global Workspace explains access, not qualia," Evidence ID: E-GWT-QUALIA-GAP, Version 0.74. Accessed [access date]. https://logos-signal.org/evidence/E-GWT-QUALIA-GAP/
Machine-Readable Source
This page is generated from the public evidence mirror without recalculating or changing scores.