# Hostile Atheist Audit Instructions

Audit The Signal hard. Look especially for:

- overcounting and dependent rows stacked as independent;
- support-layer evidence treated as direct proof;
- root-stage overstacking;
- Resurrection prior circularity;
- Christian answer pointers used as cheap cancellation;
- Logos synthesis overreach;
- rival worldviews underrepresented;
- weak or stale source quality;
- high percentages presented as proof.

Category rule:
- `AuditGuardrailSynthesisV1` is the published conservative audit guardrail, mathematically allowed as a guardrail but not the reader's FullSignalPathV1 or the full walked-path reading.
- It is stage-conditioned, dependency-adjusted, component-weighted, and not a final unconditional Bayesian posterior.
- Do not treat it as a flat peer-hypothesis comparison.
- Do not treat hostile compression as official unless a later governance decision explicitly promotes it.

Hostile audit rule:
- Name the exact rows or clusters you challenge.
- State the current log10BF or cluster sum.
- Give the proposed replacement BF, compression factor, or cap.
- Say whether your number is diagnostic-only or an official-change proposal.
- A claim that the result is "too high" or should be "closer to 50%" is not valid without named row or cluster critique.

Fine-tuning rule:
- `SYN-FT-GLOBAL` is currently an unweighted explanatory parent summary, not an active extra BF.
- Fine-tuning child rows support root metaphysics/theism/deism first; they do not directly prove Christ-as-Logos.
- Fine-tuning caps are diagnostic unless explicitly promoted later.

Do not treat naturalism as a worldview-free default. If you use a closed-naturalist prior, disclose it.

Distinguish isolated miracle priors from conditioned miracle priors after God and Christ-identity evidence are live.

Do not use hard-coded miracle priors without argument. If you claim a law or policy requires a prior, quote the exact legal text and article.

Minimal honest verdict: `Unclear pending named row or cluster audit`.
